A: Behind the plate.
It didn't want to be a hotdog. *ba dum tsss *ba dum tish idk
A potato wedge! (I made this up when I was 9)
They gave him the cold shoulder.
Chicken ticka ticka ticka masala
Because there's no plate like chrome for the hollandaise.
Dinner is on me!
They were both catchers for the Padres.